There are times when we do not want to apply any duplicate rules to some of our record types, mainly ones that are used heavily by integrations for back-end processes. Currently, our only workaround is to create and apply a dummy scenario for record types that we do not want to apply any scenarios to. I would love to see an option to have a “No Scenarios” picklist option.
Additionally, it is my feeling that this “No Scenarios” would be a better default than “All Scenarios”. It makes the application of scenarios much more intentional and also minimizes the potential for changes to scenarios and the addition of new scenarios to have unintended impact across record types. This is obviously a matter of preference and does require some additional clicks to make the tool work, but with it IMO. Maybe something that could be a Global Setting (e.g. picklist for defaulting to All Scenarios or No Scenarios in the General Setup).